1. Start with what you need made
Agencies describe themselves broadly, so begin with the job rather than the agency. A new brand identity, a website rebuild and a TV campaign call for different specialists. Write down the one or two things you need most, then look for agencies whose core service matches. Our service lists group agencies by what they actually make.
2. Check the record
A good agency leaves a public trail. Before a first call, look for:
- A real company. The trading name should lead to a Companies House entry with up-to-date accounts. Every Kanoti listing links to its entry.
- Named clients. Case studies that name the client, ideally confirmed by the client's own site or press release.
- Awards from credible bodies. Awards judged by peers (such as D&AD, the Drum or regional design awards) carry more weight than ones that charge to enter and award most entrants.
- Recent work. A portfolio updated in the last year or two shows the team that made it is probably still there.
Kanoti orders every list by this record, and nobody can pay to move up. Read how we list agencies.
3. Match size to size
A five-person studio often gives a small project senior attention all the way through. A large agency brings more disciplines and capacity for big, multi-channel work. Neither is better: the right fit is an agency for whom your project is a normal size, so you're neither their smallest client nor too big for them to handle.
4. Look for sector experience, not sector lock-in
An agency that already knows your sector learns your audience, rules and jargon faster. Browse agencies by sector to find them. Fresh eyes from outside your sector can be a strength too, especially for a brand that wants to stand apart from its competitors.
5. Decide how local you need them to be
Plenty of projects run well remotely. If you want workshops in person, a photo or video shoot nearby, or simply prefer to meet face to face, start with agencies in your area.
6. Shortlist three, and brief them all the same way
Three agencies is usually enough to compare. Send each the same written brief (our brief guide has a template) so their responses are easy to compare. Be clear about your budget: it saves everyone time and helps agencies propose something realistic.
7. Meet the people who will do the work
Ask who will work on your project day to day, and meet them. Good signs are questions about your audience and goals, honest views on what will and won't work, and a clear process with points where you review and approve.
8. Compare proposals on more than price
Look at what's included (rounds of changes, files and rights you'll own, ongoing support), how the agency will measure success, and how well they understood the brief. Ask for one or two client references and call them.
Quick checklist
- Core service matches what you need made
- Active Companies House entry
- Named clients and recent work you like
- Project size and budget suit the agency's usual work
- You've met the people who will do the work
- The proposal says clearly what's included and what you'll own